[PCP 31] Support weETH on Seamless

Overview

Chaos Labs supports listing weETH on Seamless. Our analysis and risk parameter recommendations for the initial listing are below.

weETH

Wrapped eETH (weETH) is the yield-bearing wrapper of ether.fi Staked ETH (eETH). It rapidly grew to be the largest Ethereum LRT, reaching over 2M ETH restaked in the protocol.

It has previously been assessed for use as collateral on other top protocols and found to be appropriate, including in highly leveraged situations. For example, 61% of the weETH on Ethereum, valued at $3.75B, is deposited in Aave.

Base Liquidity

There is a total supply of 40,932 weETH on Base, with 73% of this supply deposited in Aave. Its DEX liquidity on the network has been relatively steady since mid-September, with a 500 weETH for USDC swap able to be completed for under 10% price slippage.

weETH Volatility

Relative to ETH, eETH has low and decreasing volatility, with 3.62% daily annualized over the last 30 days, compared to 4.4% over the last 90. This indicates the asset has a robust peg.

LTV, Liquidation Threshold, and Liquidation Bonus

Given the asset’s deep liquidity, usage in other protocols, and low volatility relative to ETH, we recommend listing it with a 7.5% Liquidation Bonus, 72.5% LTV, and 75% LT.

Interest Rate Curve, UOptimal, and Reserve Factor

Given a similar use case, we recommend aligning the IR curve with the other LSTs in the same market. As weETH is a yield-bearing asset, we expect limited borrow demand. Thus, we recommend setting the UOptimal at 45%. We recommend setting its Reserve Factor to 45% to prevent excessive looping.

Supply and Borrow Cap

We recommend utilizing our usual methodology, setting the supply cap equivalent to 2x the liquidity available below 7.5% (LB) price slippage. We recommend a supply cap of 900 weETH, with a borrow cap set to 50% of this value.

Pricing

Given the asset’s strong peg and demonstrated history of withdrawals, we recommend pricing the asset according to its exchange rate, allowing the protocol to avoid potential liquidation cascades. This allows us also to recommend listing the asset in the ETH Correlated E-Mode.

Recommendation

Parameter Value
Isolation Mode No
Borrowable Yes
Collateral Enabled Yes
Supply Cap 900
Borrow Cap 450
Debt Ceiling -
LTV 72.5%
LT 75%
Liquidation Bonus 7.50%
Liquidation Protocol Fee 10.00%
Reserve Factor 45.00%
Variable Base 0.00%
Variable Slope1 7.00%
Variable Slope2 75.00%
Uoptimal 45.00%
E-Mode Category ETH Correlated
5 Likes

Thank you for this analysis Chaos. Given the size of this market on other platforms such as AAVE it certainly seems like an interesting asset to pursue. I think we can begin the ~5 day discussion window to see if others from the community have thoughts or insights

I think adding weETH to Seamless is a great step to diversify its existing support for wstETH and cbETH. It broadens the protocol’s appeal and provides more options for users in the ether.fi ecosystem, which makes Seamless even more versatile.

From my perspective, weETH’s adoption, liquidity, and low volatility make it a strong addition, especially with its potential for E-Mode optimization. The proposed parameters seem well-balanced, though I wonder if the supply and borrow caps could be slightly increased to better match its liquidity.

Overall, I see this as a smart move that strengthens Seamless and benefits the community.

Adding weETH potentially opens a wide spectre of opportunities for traders and new ILMs. Fully support this proposal, especially given that we have a solid risk analysis by @chaoslabs

As always, thanks for the analysis @chaoslabs ! I support listing this asset assuming there are no technical concerns/risks associated with it!

This looks like a great asset addition. weETH has proven itself, both on Base and mainnet, to be a popular LRT for Ethereum. I support listing weETH.

This discussion has passed the required discussion period of 5 days. It is now ready to move to an onchain vote. We should also consider preparations for a weETH ILM using this asset listing.

3 Likes

This proposal is live onchain, voting starts in 48 hours. Tally | Seamless Protocol | [SIP-36] Listing weETH

This onchain proposal has reached quorum and passed: Tally | Seamless Protocol | [SIP-36] Listing weETH

1 Like